Northern Winos said:
I would personally be intimidated by the Evaluation part of the Submission, but know that is probably an important part of it.
No need to be.
This is where people can say, "hey, it's not the best wine I've ever made, but it's worth a try." After our taste-testing evening on Saturday, my husband and I are determined to change the tasting notes a little. We realize the down-side of what's there now, but it's at least something.
Time permitting, we will change it around a little for the future. But that's in Version 2... Right now, Version 1 is doing its thing.
If you look at some of my recipe submissions, I have made comments about the wines I just added. "I didn't add enough sugar. There was CO2 that was annoying" etc, etc. I hated my Chamomile tea wine, my husband loved it. So, we took an "average" ofour tastes.
I used this tasting sheet as a guide for our website. It seemed to be the best one for our/the website's needs:
http://www.cellarmastersla.org/cmfest.htm
Print it out and test one of your wines with it. You will see what I mean about having some difficulty in judging it. Put your comments in it, and then a general description of what you think the taste is. Don't forget to think about the age of the wine either. Taste it again after 6 months using the same scoring sheet, different color pen.
Don't be shy about giving your opinion about the taste! We did this because there are lots of wines out there (especially mine) where you think, "Yes, it's weird, but is it any good?" That's why we included the tasting notes.
Thanks for looking, NW, I'm glad it's workin' for ya!
M.