bkisel
Junior Member
- Joined
- Jun 29, 2013
- Messages
- 3,681
- Reaction score
- 1,808
It's OK Dawg. It's hard to offend a plumber!
Well then I can safely post this without offending you...
It's OK Dawg. It's hard to offend a plumber!
Well then I can safely post this without offending you...
Both Brix and specific gravity are used to measure the sugar content of liquids. I think that both use different indirect measures based on our understanding of how light bends through a liquid (Brix) and how a body floats in a liquid (specific gravity). Brix is a measure of the percentage of sugar in a solution, specific gravity is a measure of the density of a liquid. The specific gravity could be measuring salinity (the salt content in a body of water), the amount of anti-freeze in your radiator .. or it could simply measure how dense an unknown liquid was compared to distilled water.
All kinds of "things" can affect the density of a liquid - including temperature , but home wine makers typically use specific gravity as a good enough indication of the amount of sugar in their must or wine (because the assumption is that sugar is the one substance in the liquid that will have a real significant impact on the density of that liquid).
Brix is a measure of the percentage of sugar in the fruit (grapes or strawberries or passion fruit - whatever..), although , my lack of detailed knowledge not withstanding , I think Brix still uses an indirect method to determine this - usually, the refraction of light by a liquid - the greater the bending of the light the more sugar there is in the liquid since, again, the working assumption is that the only thing in the juice that will significantly contribute to a change in the refractive index is the amount of sugar in the liquid (water)- but refractometers can also be used to measure salinity and levels of anti-freeze ...but they need to be calibrated for those measurements. That is because the same quantity of say, table salt in water does not bend light at the same angle that sucrose will bend a beam of light - so you cannot use a refractometer calibrated for measuring salinity to measure Brix in any simple way. And brewers and wine makers who use refractometers to measure the sugar content of their wort or must need to do all kinds of calculations when they use the same tool after they have pitched the yeast because there is alcohol in the liquid - the meaning of the angle at which light bends (the sugar content or the density of the liquid) is based on the base solution being water , not a mix of alcohol and water.
It's OK Dawg. It's hard to offend a plumber!
Just curious why you prefer the Brix scale. Do you feel that it's more accurate? Don't you have to do a lot of converting when reading a new wine recipes?
For me it is perhaps mentally easier to use brix. I think in terms of percent of sugar (or percent of sugar remaining when fermenting). I also use a light refractometer that measure in brix, so I tend to just keep going with that scale.
Do you not have to do all kinds of calculations to recalibrate your refractometer when there is alcohol in the wine? Light bends differently when there is alcohol in the liquid and the more "alcohol" to "water" in the liquid , the greater the difference in the angle of refraction?
Aha! so you use the brix scale on the hydrometer... I thought you meant that you used the brix scale on your refractometer...
Enter your email address to join: