Too much or not enought water?!
So I took a bottle of my wine to a local brewpub where they make and serve the same wine for a side by side comparison. Talking with the winemaker we both agreed mine was lighter in color and taste. Mine also has a slight carbination. The thought being 1) too much water and 2) not enough degassing. I know for a fact that we had some trouble degassing, the more we tried, it seemed the more foam we got. The suggestion was next time to transfer to a primary for degassing as the carboy shape naturally funnels the foam up and out...
Now regarding the water, I want to say I was meticulous about measuring the water. to the point where my 6-gal mark was about a pint below what the 6-gal mark on the primary was.
So today I'm getting ready to make another kit and want to confirm the correct volumn of water and lo-and-behold, it appears that the actual 6-gal mark on the primary is correct, and if that's the case, then when I made my wine I actually used LESS water that the kit called for...
Now the kit very specifically says that making it to a full 23 Litres (6 US gallons) is crucital to the functioning of the fining agents and stability of the finished wine. If you make it to any other volumn, it will not turn out correctly, and any problems you may experience may not be solvable.
Is it possible that by not having quite enough water, it came out weeker?
As far as the SG, for the most part I hit the mark all the way through;
Primary 1.048 - 1.052 (1.048)
Secondary 1.010 or less (1.002)
Stabilising 0.996 or less (0.998 verified stability twice)
I'm so confused!
So I'm going to start my next kit and I'm going to add MORE water (i.e. the correct amount) and hope for the best...
UGH!!