Welcome to the forum Ron. I have done the Amarone Renaissance, and have to say after nine months in the bottle it is very good. Still has room for a little improvement with more time, but very good now. The only all juice I have done was Chardasia, and I gave it a full year before trying, glad I did, it also turned out very well. With the all juice actually a dollar less, and the fact it is all juice, no water added, I would go that route. I don't think the age time is truly less for the Renaissance to reach its full potential, both benefit from a year or two of aging.