JohnT said:Gregin: I understand your concern about diminishing the wine flavor.
I find, however, that if you add everclear, you add nothing in the way of flavor. From a flavor point of view, my thinking is that it would be no different than adding water.
Brandy, on the other hand, adds flavor. One that I like.
This is just my simple opinion. Others may disagree.
Thanks. I certainly respect your opinion and agree that brandy may give really nice flavors to the port. I think this discussion provides inspiration for some experimentation.
I think adding 40% brandy certainly can add brandy flavor. But you are adding a lot more water to the port than adding 95% everclear. The EC could keep the grape (or fruit) concentration in the wine from being washed out. And it isn't like adding water in terms of flavor. The added alcohol helps to extract mire flavors from the grape must. That being said, if I ever make port commercially I would try to source a quality high proof brandy from a distiller to fortify with in order to be as traditional as possible. That isn't an option for the home winemaker.
I think next year I will split a batch and make it two ways. Take half and stop fermentation half way through with EC. The other half will be fermented dry and fortified with 40% brandy. It may take a few years to get the results. But it would be interesting o compare the two methods with the same grapes.