Quantcast

any way to counteract sodium benzoate before fermentation?

Wine Making Talk

Help Support Wine Making Talk:

Joined
Apr 25, 2020
Messages
37
Reaction score
13
I normally make sweet red wine from grape juice for daily drinking with dinner, but the fun I have with wine making is from making different kinds of wines. using frozen fruit and juices, I've made lots of different kinds. Blueberry, cherry, mango, tropical passion fruit blend, cranberry raspberry, pomegranate plum, even coffee and kilju (Finnish fermented sugar water - which i wasn't fond of, had a very off aftertaste; even with a few koolaid packets added to it, it was still nasty)

I'd really like to make something strange and exotic like using sno cone syrup or sodastream syrup or something like that. (the thought of mountain dew or cotton candy flavored wine to surprise friends with sounds amazing) but alas, most of these have sodium benzoate as a preservative, which as we all know would not be very friendly to fermenting yeast.

is there anything I could add that would counteract the sodium benzoate so that something like these would be ferment-able?
 

BernardSmith

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2011
Messages
3,264
Reaction score
1,376
Location
Saratoga Springs
You might try pitching four or five times the amount of yeast you normally pitch. My understanding is that the preservative binds to individual yeast cells and so there is a limited amount of benzoate that is available. If the cell count is larger then you MIGHT have a successful fermentation. But if I were you I would look for substrates that were preservative free to avoid the problem.
 
Joined
Apr 25, 2020
Messages
37
Reaction score
13
Yeah, i thought of that, more yeast might do the job, or it might just be a waste of 4 or 5 or more packs of yeast. Finding flavor syrups by the gallon like that without preservatives doesn't have many results, at least on amazon. Found a couple organic ones that didn't seem to have any preservatives, but the flavors were basic like grape or cherry so there isn't much point since I could make those with fruit or fruit juice, or the bottles were so small it would be fairly expensive just to make a 1 gallon batch.
I was hoping there was something I could add that would give the yeast a better chance of success so I didn't end up wasting several packets of yeast.
 

BernardSmith

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2011
Messages
3,264
Reaction score
1,376
Location
Saratoga Springs
ah... but you are going to dilute the syrup. The amount of preservative used (I believe) is to inhibit the spoilage of the volume of liquid. So, for example, lemon juice has sorbates but that does not prevent anyone from making "skeeter pee" (AKA alcoholic lemonade) from concentrated lemon juice. Diluting the syrups is going to also dilute the preservatives.
 
Joined
Apr 25, 2020
Messages
37
Reaction score
13
Yes, I was thinking of doing a 1 to 1 mix, depending on the thickness of the syrup. Ultimately it would depend on the syrup. Also, I'm thinking this would be a good job for lalvin ec-1118 yeast. what do you think? That seems to work well on oddball brews (like coffee for example.)

I think it might just be worth a try. To me, experimenting like this is half the fun of brewing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kmk

stickman

Veteran Winemaker
Joined
Jun 16, 2014
Messages
1,638
Reaction score
1,528
If you are trying to ferment something unusual, be sure you check the pH before adding yeast. If the syrup is designed for a beverage that is very sweet, then the pH may be very low, the syrup may include phosphoric acid. Yeast already have a difficult time fermenting at very low pH's, and in addition, Sodium Benzoate is more effective preventing fermentation at lower pH's, so there may be a couple of things working against you.
 

ThunderFred

Springfield Illinois
Joined
Jul 11, 2017
Messages
47
Reaction score
34
Location
Springfield IL
Why not just buy already fermented alcohol like everclear of vodka, dilute it to wine like alcohol content and flavor with the syrup? You'll be adding sugar to make alcohol and back sweetening to get the flavor back to where it's at. Why not just skip the extra steps and make a cocktail?
 
  • Like
Reactions: kmk

ThunderFred

Springfield Illinois
Joined
Jul 11, 2017
Messages
47
Reaction score
34
Location
Springfield IL
I suppose the fun is in drinking it. You could adjust the mix and try it over and over in very short time. Or you could spend weeks trying to get to the same point. For me, the magic in making my own wine comes from the ingredients and process. Fermenting what is essentially prison hooch out of flavored syrup doesn't sound like all that much fun to me. More power to you, there's plenty of room for us all to enjoy this hobby in different ways. Good luck.
 
Joined
Apr 25, 2020
Messages
37
Reaction score
13
most of my wine making is just sweet red table wine for daily drinking with dinner, so I like the fun of experimenting with new things, like the coffee wine. Everyone said "why?' but it's actually quite good if you like coffee (and I do) but the fun was doing what most people though was a waste of time and making something good in the process.
 

BernardSmith

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2011
Messages
3,264
Reaction score
1,376
Location
Saratoga Springs
Coffee wine (or coffee mead) is a challenging wine to make. Most folk who try to ferment on coffee suggest that the wine (or mead) is very bitter and it does not really improve with age. But then most folk who make coffee wine tend to make coffee (hot or cold brewed) and then add the sugar and so make a wine with yeast. What was your approach?
In my opinion a better method is to treat the coffee a lot like one might treat nuts when making , say a hazelnut wine - and so you use perhaps an ounce or two of beans that you crack (not crush ) and you add those to the secondary rather than the primary , removing the beans when the flavor profile is what you want.
 
Joined
Apr 25, 2020
Messages
37
Reaction score
13
i have a small 5 cup coffee pot. I took 4 pots of strong, double brewed coffee, added 5 cups sugar, 2 tsp nutrient, 1/2 tsp pectin, and the grounds from all 4 batches with ec-1118 yeast in a 1 gallon glass jug with airlock. brewed for a month to 10.5% abv. cleared with bentonite clay for 1 week then back-sweetened and added a bit of hazelnut syrup to taste, bottled and aged for 6 months. was good but will probably be better in another 6 months.

might try it your way next time.
 

M38A1

Supporting Members
WMT Supporter
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
310
Reaction score
68
Glad I found this thread... lol

One of my first experiments was a coffee wine. Straight up Folgers. I need to see how that's coming along now that it's been in the bottle about a year.

And then there was the Cherry Kool-Aid. That was interesting and drinkable. Lot of people liked it too.

I've made a successful batch of pink lemonade by using cotton candy floss sugar. Ran it down to dry, than back sweetened with the same cotton candy floss sugar as invert. That was some good stuff.

Last night I pitched some RedStar Montrachet at a gallon of bubblegum snow-cone syrup. Not too hopeful about this one at the moment but we'll see. I had to dilute it about 75% to get it 'thinner', then tossed two cups of sugar/one cup water to bring the SG back up to 1.08. A little yeast nutrient, some acid blend, a bit of tannin. If this doesn't seem to be active in another day, I'll try some EC1118 and see where that goes.
 
Joined
Apr 25, 2020
Messages
37
Reaction score
13
Glad I found this thread... lol

One of my first experiments was a coffee wine. Straight up Folgers. I need to see how that's coming along now that it's been in the bottle about a year.

And then there was the Cherry Kool-Aid. That was interesting and drinkable. Lot of people liked it too.

I've made a successful batch of pink lemonade by using cotton candy floss sugar. Ran it down to dry, than back sweetened with the same cotton candy floss sugar as invert. That was some good stuff.

Last night I pitched some RedStar Montrachet at a gallon of bubblegum snow-cone syrup. Not too hopeful about this one at the moment but we'll see. I had to dilute it about 75% to get it 'thinner', then tossed two cups of sugar/one cup water to bring the SG back up to 1.08. A little yeast nutrient, some acid blend, a bit of tannin. If this doesn't seem to be active in another day, I'll try some EC1118 and see where that goes.
My kinda guy! How did you do the Cherry Kool-Aid? I thought about that but thought the preservatives would make it too hard to ferment so that's why I tried making Kilju and adding Kool-Aid packets to it. The Kilju was nasty and the Kool-Aid didn't help!

The Cotton Candy sugar idea sounds great! I'll have to try that!

The BubbleGum snow cone syrup is why I made this thread. I would love to know how yours turned out.
 

M38A1

Supporting Members
WMT Supporter
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
310
Reaction score
68
My kinda guy! How did you do the Cherry Kool-Aid? I thought about that but thought the preservatives would make it too hard to ferment so that's why I tried making Kilju and adding Kool-Aid packets to it. The Kilju was nasty and the Kool-Aid didn't help!

The Cotton Candy sugar idea sounds great! I'll have to try that!

The BubbleGum snow cone syrup is why I made this thread. I would love to know how yours turned out.
The Kool-Aid was, um... interesting. Horribly harsh for the first six months or so, then it mellowed out to be ok. My cotton candy sugar came out good after a few months. I'm assuming it will only get better with time. And the bubble gum snow cone syrup is just sitting there in clarification at the moment. I'll probably rack that off tomorrow. I'm not sure my sparkloid made a dent in it or it's just a dark turquoise color that my light can't shine through. lol
 

M38A1

Supporting Members
WMT Supporter
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
310
Reaction score
68
I'd love to see your recipes for those 3. maybe try bentonite if the sparkloid doesn't work?
Let me dig those up for you...

I racked the snow cone syrup one this weekend and it's just thick. Both in viscosity AND taste. The lady friend said it's awesome. I wanted to spit it out. I "think" it's a heavy glycerin based sugar in some way because it's heavy across the tongue. I recall adding a bunch of water to the syrup to thin it, but apparently not enough. But if she's happy - I'm happy. She said it reminded her of being a kid at the country fair so I guess it worked. lol even made her tongue blue!
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Top