BartReeder said:
Do you know now what ratios you will be blending the Cab. sauv., the cab. franc, and the merlot?
I will not know what ratio will be until the actual blending takes place. Of the blends that I have made in the past, I compared the following against one another: Pure A, Pure B, Pure C, equal thirds A/B/C, 50% A/25% B/25% C, 25% A/50% B/25% C, 25% A/25% B/50% C. In each case even with multiple people tasting, there was one blend that stood out significantly from the others. Further deviation could be tested from this point, but I hadn't done a comparison past what I have noted here. I feel that taste should rule the blending determination, provided there aren't specific corrections that need to be made (blending for the purpose of pH or acid adjustments, for example).
BartReeder said:
1. Unlike your blending of 23 L kits/frozen juice, have you tried blending more concentrated kits together like 16 liter kits with 10 L kits (different varietals)?
The 10L kit that I have made to date was for a friend. I stick with the largest amount of juice possible with the kits that I make. The two blends that are listed on my 'cellar' web page were each made from 18L-23L kits, one a Bordeaux blend with WE and MM kits and the other a Meglioli Super Tuscan blend.
BartReeder said:
2. What about blending a 23 L kit of a given varietal (e.g., cab. sauv.) with a more concentrated kit, like a 16 L or 10 L cab. sauv. kits?
I reference this further down, but I wouldn't do it - I use the best materials I can get. I'd rather blend the same juice fermented on different yeasts or oaked differently, for example into each other than drop the effective quality of the product. In the end, however, your taste must rule your decisions - do what you like.
BartReeder said:
My thought is the concentrated kit would be "thickened" by the all-juice portion, so it would not be so thin. On the downside, it might just end up with 60 bottles of thin, disappointing wine. Any opinions about those ideas?
For me, I haven't tasted a kit wine that wasn't thin in the mouth. Kits seem to make wines that have a feel of water in the mouth, regardless of flavor. I have consumed wines that felt like I was drinking roast beef - very chewy stuff - I can't see a kit ever coming close to that based on the raw materials used. While this is fine for a light white, it means that for me, the 'bigger' the red, the less a kit can hope to compete against commercial wine in the mouthfeel department. Thin in flavor is a different story, and I believe that my tests with different yeasts that enhance varietal characteristics on fermentations help compensate for the flavor side of things but still can't beef up a wine that wasn't exposed to skins or didn't have enough extraction. The kit wines that I have made will likely become table wine experiments to help me get more experience for making wine from grapes in the future. To address your question more specifically, I would fall back on the winemaking adage- "use the best quality source materials you can." If you blend a good wine with a weak wine, there will not be a magic that happens and turns it into amazing. In essence, it would be a dilution.
- Jim