Bart the important thing to remember is that we all do not always have ideal grapes to work with every year. For you small home winemakers, you can buy kits or source a certain grape, but those of us who depend on our own grapes for wine, we need to learn to make the best from what we have- and I will guarantee you it is not sub-par wine in any way. Pinot is typically a poor coloring wine and can benefit from the extra color extraction. I use the Catawba as an example here in that I can attain a naturally pigmented pink wine using this method and it is one of the top selling wines we have. Other wineries that use conventional methods need to mix in a red wine for color and hope they don't change the flavor profile too badly or they end up with a straw colored wine. Under cold conditions, the wine is really in no danger of oxidation as long as you handle it with proper punchdowns, etc afterwards.
Could not agree more folks!
There are as many different ways to make wine as there are tastes in wine. Everything on posted this forum site is simply expressed opinions. It is a well understood rule that no-one has the right to "put down" another for their preferred method..
(That is, unless they use welches)
Enter your email address to join: