I just priced the same 10 cases from George. He is $7.49 more. Given George's customer service and Mark's packing, I would go with FVW for the order. The Ebay guy implies that breakage is to be expected and would leave you with the loss. I doubt George would, and having ordered many cases of bottles from FVW with zero broken on arrival it's a no-brainer.
Still, I'd like to know where this guy is. Someone local can buy the 10 cases for a dollar and pick them up.